Mexican Cantina II - Bay Street
Mexican food, margaritas and a lively neighborhood Cantina at 1189 Bay Street in Rosebank, on Staten Island's North Shore. SEE MENUORDER ONLINE
BAY STREET • ROSEBANK, STATEN ISLAND’S NORTH SHORE
MEXICAN RESTAURANT ON BAY STREET IN STATEN ISLAND
Mexican Cantina’s Bay Street restaurant is located at 1189 Bay Street, Staten Island, NY 10305, in Rosebank, on Staten Island’s North Shore. Bay Street opened in summer 2026 as Mexican Cantina’s second Staten Island location. The neighborhood restaurant brings made-to-order Mexican food, generous portions, full-bar drinks and a lively Cantina atmosphere to Bay Street.
Guests looking for a Mexican restaurant in Rosebank, on Staten Island’s North Shore, can enjoy tacos, burritos, quesadillas, empanadas, guacamole, margaritas and other Mexican Cantina favorites for lunch, dinner or drinks.
MEXICAN FOOD, MARGARITAS AND A NORTH SHORE NIGHT OUT
The regular menu brings together Mexican Cantina favorites including tacos, burritos, quesadillas, empanadas, guacamole and other made-to-order dishes. Both locations use the same menu, so guests can review the current menu before dining in or placing an order.
The Bay Street dining room and bar offer a casual, energetic setting for family meals, dinner with friends, drinks and group gatherings in Rosebank, on Staten Island’s North Shore.
VISIT OR ORDER FROM BAY STREET
Mexican Cantina is at 1189 Bay Street, Staten Island, NY 10305. Use the Bay Street Grubhub listing for online ordering or choose directions for a route to the restaurant.
Additional delivery services may also list Mexican Cantina. Confirm the restaurant address before checkout because availability, fees and delivery areas vary by platform.
CATERING AND PARTY ORDERS
Mexican Cantina offers catering and party-sized food for family gatherings, celebrations, office meals and other group occasions. Catering covers broader service options, while the Party Menu focuses on party-sized selections.
1189 BAY STREET
1189 Bay Street
Staten Island, NY 10305 [map]
Phone: TBD.
Mexican food, margaritas and a lively neighborhood Cantina atmosphere in Rosebank, on Staten Island’s North Shore.
KITCHEN HOURS
The 2019 SILive.com story covered Mexican Cantina’s menu, including handmade tortillas, quesadilla pizza, burgers and more. See the current Menu for the latest selections.
ORDER MEXICAN CANTINA ONLINE
Choose an ordering service below and confirm the selected restaurant address before checkout. Availability, fees and delivery areas are managed by each platform.
BAY STREET GALLERY
See Mexican Cantina food, margaritas and restaurant atmosphere.
CATERING AND PARTY ORDERS
CATERING AND PARTIES MADE EASIER
Planning food for a party, family gathering or special event? Mexican Cantina offers catering information and a separate Party Menu for party-sized selections. Both locations use the same catering system, so the service options provide a clear way to compare the available paths before placing an order.
Review Catering for broader service options or open the Party Menu when the focus is food for a group.
WHAT DO YOU NEED?
Jump directly to the information guests most often need before visiting, ordering or planning a group meal.
QUICK ANSWERS
BAY STREET FAQ
Answers to common questions about the address, menu, ordering and group-food options.
WHERE IS MEXICAN CANTINA ON BAY STREET?
Mexican Cantina is located at 1189 Bay Street, Staten Island, NY 10305, in Rosebank, on Staten Island’s North Shore.
WHICH MENU DOES BAY STREET USE?
Bay Street uses the shared Mexican Cantina menu. Review the current Menu for tacos, burritos, quesadillas, empanadas, guacamole and other selections.
CAN I ORDER ONLINE FOR BAY STREET?
Use the approved Bay Street Grubhub listing and confirm 1189 Bay Street as the selected restaurant address before checkout.
DOES MEXICAN CANTINA OFFER CATERING AND PARTY OPTIONS?
Mexican Cantina uses one catering system for both locations. Review Catering for broader service options and the Party Menu for party-sized food selections.
WHAT ARE THE KITCHEN HOURS AT BAY STREET?
Kitchen hours are currently listed as TBD for Sunday through Saturday.